Skip to main content

CAIR California

San Francisco, Somerville, And Oakland All Adopted A Ban On Face Surveillance Technology – Why Won’t Berkeley?

After the Oakland City Council’s decision to pass the Ban on Face Surveillance Technology Ordinance, President Kaplan and members of the civil liberties coalition released the following statements:

On Tuesday, July 16, 2019, the Oakland City Council unanimously adopted an ordinance prohibiting city staff from acquiring or using face surveillance technology, or outsourcing such use. The ordinance was supported by a large coalition of immigrants’ rights and civil liberties organizations, and sponsored by Council President Rebecca Kaplan.

Council President Kaplan, an honors graduate of MIT, states: “I welcome emerging technologies that improve our lives and facilitate city governance, but when multiple studies show a technology is flawed, biased, and is having unprecedented, chilling effects to our freedom of speech and religion, we have to take stand. It is important to build trust and good relationships between community and police and to remedy racial bias, however this flawed technology could make those problems worse. The right to privacy and the right to equal protection are fundamental and we cannot surrender them.”

“Facial recognition technology’s unreliability is one of several concerns for civil rights groups and targeted communities,” said Sameena Usman, Government Relations Coordinator for the San Francisco office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations. “The American Muslim community already lives with fear of surveillance and government use of facial recognition technology would only serve to further chill our ability to practice our First Amendment rights.”

“We applaud the Oakland City Council for taking measures to protect targeted communities, and we want to recognize the leadership of the project sponsor, Council President Kaplan, said Brian Hofer, Founder and Executive Director of Secure Justice, and Chair of Oakland’s Privacy Advisory Commission. “San Francisco, Somerville, and Oakland easily adopted such a ban, so why is Berkeley dragging its feet with a similar measure introduced by Councilmember Kate Harrison?

“Of the seven jurisdictions in California, Berkeley is the only entity operating under the ACLU model surveillance ordinance that has been caught repeatedly violating it. Top Berkeley administrators misled the Council and public about the nature of cameras recently installed at San Pablo Park, which include powerful video analytics. These same administrators repeatedly affirmed in writing to the City Council that they were using such technology, until the media began inquiring. We’ve also recently learned that the City Manager used false information to support a competitive bidding waiver. So why would we trust them with the most radically intrusive technology developed in our lifetime, when they repeatedly flaunt their own laws? Berkeley must ban dangerous face surveillance technology.”

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Find What You’re Looking For